Burden of Proof under Qanun-e-Shahadat (Arts. 117-129) LAW-GAT

· 6 min read

In this guide
  1. The general rule: Article 117
  2. On whom the burden lies: Article 118
  3. Burden of a particular fact: Article 119
  4. Facts needed to make evidence admissible: Article 120
  5. General exceptions: Article 121
  6. Facts especially within knowledge: Article 122
  7. Presumptions of life and death: Articles 123 and 124
  8. Other burdens and presumptions
  9. "May presume", "shall presume" and "conclusive proof"
  10. Burden versus standard of proof
  11. Sample LAW-GAT questions
  12. Frequently Asked Questions

Burden of proof decides who loses if nothing is proved. That makes it one of the most practical ideas in the law of evidence, and one of the easiest to test in an MCQ. LAW-GAT questions on burden of proof under the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984 usually come from Articles 117 to 124, plus the presumption numbers in Articles 123, 124 and 128. This guide walks through them in order.

The general rule: Article 117

Article 117(1) says that whoever desires any court to give judgment as to any legal right or liability dependent on the existence of facts which he asserts must prove that those facts exist. Article 117(2) adds that when a person is bound to prove the existence of any fact, it is said that the burden of proof lies on that person.

HEC has blanked out both "must" and "burden of proof" in past papers.

On whom the burden lies: Article 118

The burden of proof in a suit or proceeding lies on that person who would fail if no evidence at all were given on either side. This is the test you apply when an MCQ describes a fact pattern and asks who must prove.

Burden of a particular fact: Article 119

The burden of proof as to any particular fact lies on the person who wishes the court to believe in its existence, unless a law provides that the proof of that fact shall lie on a particular person. For example, if A prosecutes B for theft and wishes the court to believe that B admitted the theft to C, A must prove the admission. If B wishes the court to believe he was elsewhere at the time (an alibi), B must prove it.

Facts needed to make evidence admissible: Article 120

The burden of proving any fact necessary to be proved in order to enable a person to give evidence of another fact is on the person who wishes to give that evidence. For instance, a party who wants to prove a dying declaration must first prove the death of the declarant.

General exceptions: Article 121

When a person is accused of an offence, the burden of proving circumstances bringing the case within any of the general exceptions in the PPC, or within any special exception or proviso, is on him, and the court shall presume the absence of such circumstances.

So if an accused pleads insanity under section 84 PPC or private defence under section 96, he must establish it. Courts accept that this burden is lighter than the prosecution's; the accused need only show a reasonable probability, often through the circumstances of the case itself. For the defences themselves, see general exceptions in PPC.

Facts especially within knowledge: Article 122

When any fact is especially within the knowledge of any person, the burden of proving that fact is on him. The illustration: a person travelling without a ticket bears the burden of proving that he had one.

Presumptions of life and death: Articles 123 and 124

These two numbers are asked repeatedly:

ArticleSituationBurden
123A man is shown to have been alive within thirty years, and the question is whether he is alive or deadOn the person who affirms he is dead
124A man has not been heard of for seven years by those who would naturally have heard of him if he were aliveOn the person who affirms he is alive

Note the shift: within thirty years the presumption favours life; after seven years of silence the burden flips.

Other burdens and presumptions

  • Article 126: when a person is shown to be in possession of anything, the burden of proving that he is not the owner is on the person who affirms it.
  • Article 127: where one party stands in a position of active confidence towards the other (a fiduciary relationship), the burden of proving the good faith of a transaction between them is on the party in active confidence.
  • Article 128: a child born during the continuance of a valid marriage, not earlier than six lunar months from the date of the marriage, or within two years after its dissolution (the mother remaining unmarried), is conclusive proof of legitimacy, unless the husband disowns the child.
  • Article 129: the court may presume the existence of any fact it thinks likely to have happened, having regard to the common course of natural events, human conduct and public and private business. Illustrations include presuming that a person in possession of stolen goods soon after the theft is the thief or receiver, and that an accomplice is unworthy of credit unless corroborated.

"May presume", "shall presume" and "conclusive proof"

Article 2 explains these three levels:

  • May presume: the court may regard the fact as proved unless disproved, or may call for proof of it.
  • Shall presume: the court shall regard the fact as proved unless and until it is disproved.
  • Conclusive proof: the court shall regard the other fact as proved and shall not allow evidence to disprove it.

Article 129 is a "may presume" provision; Article 128 uses "conclusive proof".

Burden versus standard of proof

The burden of proof says who must prove; the standard says how much. In criminal cases the prosecution must prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt, and if it fails to discharge its burden the accused is acquitted; any doubt goes to the accused. In civil cases, matters are decided on a preponderance of evidence (balance of probabilities). Both points have been asked in LAW-GAT.

Sample LAW-GAT questions

  1. Art. 117(1): whoever asserts a fact (a) must (b) may (c) may allege (d) shall swear prove it.
  2. Art. 122: when a fact is especially within one's knowledge, the burden is on (a) the Court (b) that person (c) the opposite party (d) both.
  3. Art. 124: not heard of for (a) four (b) seven (c) nine (d) eleven years.
  4. Civil cases are decided on (a) prima facie evidence (b) proof beyond doubt (c) preponderance of evidence (d) confession.

Find more in the Qanun-e-Shahadat MCQs. Use Practice mode to learn, then Test mode for exam speed. The other big evidence topics are admission and confession and examination of witnesses. Add the numbers above to your list of numbers to memorise for LAW-GAT.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who bears the burden of proof in a criminal case?

The prosecution, which must prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The accused bears a burden only for specific matters, such as bringing his case within a general exception under Article 121.

What is the test in Article 118?

The burden lies on the person who would fail if no evidence at all were given on either side.

When is a person presumed dead under the Qanun-e-Shahadat?

When he has not been heard of for seven years by those who would naturally have heard of him if alive, the burden of proving he is alive shifts to the person who says so (Article 124).

Is Article 129 a mandatory presumption?

No. It is a "may presume" provision. The court has discretion to draw or not draw the presumption in light of the facts.

Keep reading