Examination of Witnesses under Qanun-e-Shahadat for LAW-GAT

· 6 min read

In this guide
  1. Order of production and admissibility (Articles 130 and 131)
  2. The three stages of examination (Articles 132 and 133)
  3. Special witnesses (Articles 134 and 135)
  4. Leading questions (Articles 136 to 138)
  5. Cross-examination: what is allowed (Articles 140 to 149)
  6. Hostile witnesses (Article 150)
  7. Impeaching credit (Article 151)
  8. Corroboration and refreshing memory
  9. Court's questions, oath claims and modern devices
  10. Sample LAW-GAT questions
  11. Frequently Asked Questions

How witnesses are examined is the most practical part of the law of evidence, and the last major block of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984. Articles 130 to 166 govern who examines a witness first, what questions may be asked, when leading questions are allowed, and how a witness's credit can be attacked. In LAW-GAT, examination of witnesses under the Qanun-e-Shahadat produces many quick, scoreable questions because the definitions are short and precise.

Order of production and admissibility (Articles 130 and 131)

  • Article 130: the order in which witnesses are produced and examined is regulated by the law and practice relating to civil and criminal procedure (the CPC and CrPC), and in the absence of such law, by the discretion of the court.
  • Article 131: the judge decides the admissibility of evidence and admits it only if the fact, if proved, would be relevant.

The three stages of examination (Articles 132 and 133)

StageDefinition (Art. 132)Who conducts it
Examination-in-chiefExamination of a witness by the party who calls himCalling party
Cross-examinationExamination of a witness by the adverse partyAdverse party
Re-examinationExamination, subsequent to cross-examination, by the party who called himCalling party

Article 133 sets the order: witnesses are first examined-in-chief, then (if the adverse party so desires) cross-examined, then (if the calling party so desires) re-examined. Further rules:

  • Examination-in-chief and cross-examination must relate to relevant facts, but cross-examination need not be confined to the facts the witness spoke about in chief.
  • Re-examination is directed to the explanation of matters referred to in cross-examination.
  • If a new matter is introduced in re-examination with the court's permission, the adverse party may further cross-examine on it.

Special witnesses (Articles 134 and 135)

  • Article 134: a person summoned only to produce a document does not become a witness by producing it, and cannot be cross-examined unless he is called as a witness.
  • Article 135: witnesses to character may be cross-examined and re-examined.

Leading questions (Articles 136 to 138)

A leading question is one that suggests the answer the person putting it wishes or expects to receive (Art. 136).

  • Article 137: leading questions must not be asked in examination-in-chief or re-examination if objected to by the adverse party, except with the court's permission. The court shall permit them on matters that are introductory, undisputed, or in its opinion already sufficiently proved.
  • Article 138: leading questions may be asked in cross-examination.

Remember: leading questions are the cross-examiner's tool.

Cross-examination: what is allowed (Articles 140 to 149)

  • Article 140: a witness may be cross-examined on his previous written statements; to contradict him by the writing, his attention must first be drawn to the relevant parts.
  • Article 141: in cross-examination a witness may be asked questions which tend to test his veracity, to discover who he is and what his position in life is, or to shake his credit by injuring his character, even if the answer may incriminate him.
  • The articles that follow let the court decide when a witness is compelled to answer questions about credit, and require reasonable grounds before such questions are asked.
  • The court may forbid indecent and scandalous questions unless they relate to facts in issue, and under Article 148 it shall forbid questions intended to insult or annoy, or needlessly offensive in form.
  • When a witness has answered a question relevant only to shake his credit, no evidence is ordinarily given to contradict him (with limited exceptions).

Hostile witnesses (Article 150)

The court may, in its discretion, permit the person who calls a witness to put any questions to him that might be put in cross-examination by the adverse party. In practice this is used when a party's own witness turns against it, commonly called a hostile witness. The evidence of a hostile witness is not washed off entirely; the court may accept the parts it finds reliable.

Impeaching credit (Article 151)

The credit of a witness may be impeached by the adverse party, or with the court's consent by the party who calls him:

  1. by the evidence of persons who testify that they believe the witness to be unworthy of credit;
  2. by proof that the witness has been bribed, or has accepted an offer of a bribe or any other corrupt inducement to give his evidence;
  3. by proof of former statements inconsistent with any part of his evidence which is liable to be contradicted.

Corroboration and refreshing memory

  • Article 153: in order to corroborate the testimony of a witness, any former statement made by him relating to the same fact, at or about the time it took place, or before any authority legally competent to investigate the fact, may be proved. This is how an FIR is used to corroborate its maker, as explained in FIR under section 154 CrPC.
  • Article 155: a witness may refresh his memory by referring to a writing made by himself at the time of the transaction or soon afterwards; with the court's permission he may refer to a copy.

Court's questions, oath claims and modern devices

  • Article 161: the judge may, to discover or obtain proper proof of relevant facts, ask any question he pleases, in any form, at any time, of any witness or party.
  • Article 164: in cases where the court thinks fit, it may allow any evidence that has become available because of modern devices or techniques. Under this article, CCTV footage of a fact in issue has been treated as admissible, subject to proof of authenticity.

Sample LAW-GAT questions

  1. Art. 132(2): examination by the (a) court (b) adverse party (c) accused (d) calling party is cross-examination.
  2. Art. 136: a question suggesting the desired answer is (a) significant (b) relevant (c) substantive (d) leading.
  3. Art. 138: leading questions may be asked in (a) examination-in-chief (b) cross-examination (c) re-examination (d) expert testimony.
  4. Art. 134: a person summoned only to produce a document cannot be (a) cross-examined (b) examined (c) examined-in-chief (d) re-examined.

Practise these in the Qanun-e-Shahadat MCQs in Revision mode, 45 seconds a question with the answer revealed after you choose. For the rest of the Order, see Qanun-e-Shahadat important articles and burden of proof. The ethical side of handling witnesses is in legal ethics and canons of conduct.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the order of examination of a witness?

Examination-in-chief by the calling party, then cross-examination by the adverse party, then re-examination by the calling party, as set out in Article 133.

When can leading questions be asked?

Freely in cross-examination (Article 138). In examination-in-chief or re-examination only if not objected to, or with the court's permission on introductory, undisputed or already proved matters (Article 137).

What is a hostile witness?

A witness who turns against the party that called him. Under Article 150, the court may allow that party to cross-examine its own witness.

How can the credit of a witness be impeached?

Under Article 151, by testimony that he is unworthy of credit, by proof of bribery or corrupt inducement, or by proof of former inconsistent statements.

Keep reading