Doctrine of Necessity in Pakistan Explained for LAW-GAT
In this guide
The doctrine of necessity in Pakistan is the main thread running through the country's constitutional history, and you need it for LAW-GAT. Each time the army took power, the superior courts had to decide whether to resist it or accept it. Several times they accepted it, and the legal reason they gave was "necessity". If you understand how that idea developed, the cases in this chapter become a single story rather than a list of names and dates.
What is the doctrine of necessity?
The idea is old. It is usually traced to the medieval English jurist Bracton and the maxim "that which is otherwise not lawful, necessity makes lawful". It is also linked to the Roman maxim salus populi suprema lex, meaning that the welfare of the people is the supreme law.
The doctrine says that in an extraordinary emergency, an act that would normally be illegal may be treated as valid if three things are true:
- it was needed to avoid a greater harm, such as a breakdown of government;
- it went no further than the necessity required; and
- it was temporary and aimed at returning to constitutional order.
The danger is obvious. Whoever holds power can always say there was a necessity. That is why Pakistani courts were later criticised so strongly for using it.
How the doctrine of necessity developed in Pakistan
1955: the Governor-General's Reference
After the Maulvi Tamizuddin Khan case (PLD 1955 FC 240), many laws passed by the dissolved Constituent Assembly were found invalid because they lacked assent. That created a legal vacuum. Governor-General Ghulam Muhammad sent a Special Reference to the Federal Court. Chief Justice Muhammad Munir relied on necessity and Bracton's maxim to allow the Governor-General to validate those laws temporarily until a new assembly was formed. Most writers treat this as the moment the doctrine of necessity entered Pakistani law.
1958: State v. Dosso and Kelsen
Many students confuse Dosso with necessity. In State v. Dosso (PLD 1958 SC 533), Munir CJ actually relied on Hans Kelsen's theory of revolutionary legality: a successful revolution is a law-creating fact, so the new regime's orders become valid law. The question bank has asked this directly, and the correct answer is Kelsen, not necessity.
1972: Asma Jilani rejects the idea
In Asma Jilani (PLD 1972 SC 139), Chief Justice Hamoodur Rahman overruled Dosso and called Yahya Khan a usurper. The Court did accept a narrow form of "condonation": some acts of the usurper could be treated as valid where they were needed for ordinary life to carry on, such as routine administration. This limited idea of necessity became the basis for the next case.
1977: Nusrat Bhutto and "state necessity"
In Begum Nusrat Bhutto v. Chief of Army Staff (PLD 1977 SC 657), decided under Chief Justice Anwar-ul-Haq, the Court openly validated General Zia's martial law under the doctrine of state necessity. It went further than any earlier court and allowed the Chief Martial Law Administrator to make laws and even amend the Constitution. The Court said it kept its power of judicial review. In practice that power was soon taken away by the Provisional Constitution Order of 1981.
2000: Zafar Ali Shah
In Syed Zafar Ali Shah v. General Pervez Musharraf (PLD 2000 SC 869), a bench led by CJ Irshad Hasan Khan described the takeover of 12 October 1999 as extra-constitutional, then validated it on the ground of necessity. The Court gave the regime three years to hold general elections and allowed it to amend the Constitution within limits.
2009: the doctrine is buried
After General Musharraf proclaimed an emergency on 3 November 2007, the Supreme Court in Sindh High Court Bar Association v. Federation (PLD 2009 SC 879) declared the emergency and the related orders unconstitutional. It also made clear that the courts would no longer validate unconstitutional takeovers. This is generally described as the end of the doctrine of necessity in Pakistan.
The constitutional response: Article 6
Parliament also closed the door through the Constitution itself. Article 6(1) makes abrogating or subverting the Constitution by force, or conspiring to do so, high treason. Article 6(3) leaves the punishment to Majlis-e-Shoora (Parliament) to provide by law, which it did in the High Treason (Punishment) Act 1973.
The 18th Amendment (2010) strengthened Article 6 in two ways:
- holding the Constitution in abeyance now also counts as high treason;
- new clause 6(2A) says an act of high treason shall not be validated by any court, including the Supreme Court and a High Court.
The courts can no longer use necessity to validate a coup. See our summary of 18th Amendment key changes for the full list.
Timeline at a glance
| Year | Case or event | Theory used | Chief Justice |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1955 | Governor-General's Reference | Necessity (Bracton) | Muhammad Munir |
| 1958 | State v. Dosso | Kelsen's revolutionary legality | Muhammad Munir |
| 1972 | Asma Jilani | Usurpation, limited condonation | Hamoodur Rahman |
| 1977 | Nusrat Bhutto | State necessity | Anwar-ul-Haq |
| 2000 | Zafar Ali Shah | Necessity | Irshad Hasan Khan |
| 2009 | Sindh High Court Bar Association | Necessity rejected | Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry |
| 2010 | 18th Amendment | Art. 6(2A) bars validation | N/A |
How LAW-GAT tests this topic
Past papers ask short factual questions. Typical examples are:
- "Dosso validated the 1958 coup on the basis of ___". The answer is Kelsen's theory.
- "Nusrat Bhutto validated Zia's martial law under the doctrine of ___". The answer is state necessity.
- "Art. 6(1): abrogating the Constitution by force is ___". The answer is high treason.
- "Art. 6(3): punishment for high treason is provided by ___". The answer is Majlis-e-Shoora (Parliament).
Practise these on the constitutional history MCQs and the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 MCQs. Use Practice mode first, then Revision mode (45 seconds per question). For the full case list, read landmark constitutional cases for LAW-GAT.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did State v. Dosso use the doctrine of necessity?
No. Dosso relied on Hans Kelsen's theory of revolutionary legality, which says a successful revolution creates its own legal order. The doctrine of state necessity was applied openly in Begum Nusrat Bhutto (1977), and necessity was first relied on in the 1955 Governor-General's Reference.
Which case is said to have buried the doctrine of necessity?
Sindh High Court Bar Association v. Federation (PLD 2009 SC 879). It declared the emergency of 3 November 2007 unconstitutional and refused to give the legal cover that earlier courts had given to military takeovers.
What did the 18th Amendment change in Article 6?
It added holding the Constitution in abeyance to the definition of high treason. It also inserted clause (2A), which says no court, including the Supreme Court and a High Court, can validate an act of high treason.
Who first used the doctrine of necessity in Pakistan?
Chief Justice Muhammad Munir used it in the Governor-General's Special Reference of 1955. He relied on Bracton's maxim that necessity makes lawful what is otherwise unlawful.
Practise this topic
Test what you just read with real HEC past-paper questions.