Sources of Islamic Law: Quran, Sunnah, Ijma, Qiyas for LAW-GAT
In this guide
"The primary sources of Islamic law in order are ___." This is one of the most reliable questions in the Islamic jurisprudence chapter of LAW-GAT, and the answer is Qur'an, Sunnah, Ijma, Qiyas. HEC also asks about the elements of qiyas, the kinds of ijma, and which school is linked with which secondary method. This guide covers the sources of Islamic law following Nyazee's treatment.
The order of the sources
The order is usually traced to the hadith of Mu'adh bin Jabal. When the Prophet (peace be upon him) sent him to Yemen as a judge, Mu'adh said he would decide by the Book of Allah, then by the Sunnah, and then by his own reasoning. Jurists later added consensus. The accepted order is:
- Qur'an
- Sunnah
- Ijma (consensus)
- Qiyas (analogy)
The first two are revealed sources (naqli). Ijma and qiyas depend on the jurists' reasoning, though they rest on the texts. A practical point HEC has tested is that before reasoning by analogy, a jurist first checks whether there is an ijma on the issue.
1. The Qur'an
The Qur'an is the word of Allah revealed to the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him), transmitted by tawatur (mass transmission), and is the first and highest source. Only a few hundred of its verses deal directly with legal rules (ayat al-ahkam); around 500 is the figure commonly given. Its texts are either definitive (qat'i) or probable (zanni) in meaning, and this affects the strength of the rule derived from them.
2. The Sunnah
The Sunnah is what the Prophet (peace be upon him) said, did or approved. It has three forms:
- Qawli: his sayings
- Fi'li: his acts
- Taqriri: his tacit approval of what others did in his presence
By chain of transmission, the Hanafis classify reports as mutawatir (mass-transmitted), mashhur (well-known) and ahad (solitary). The Sunnah explains the Qur'an, qualifies its general terms, and lays down rules on matters the Qur'an does not address.
3. Ijma (consensus)
Ijma is the consensus of the mujtahids of the Muslim community in any period after the Prophet's death on a legal rule. Once established, it is binding.
Nyazee describes two kinds:
| Kind | Arabic | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Explicit | Ijma' sarih | All mujtahids state their opinion expressly |
| Tacit | Ijma' sukuti | Some state an opinion and the rest stay silent despite knowing of it |
Explicit ijma is definitive. Tacit ijma is weaker, and not every school accepts it.
4. Qiyas (analogy)
Qiyas extends a rule found in the texts to a new case that shares the same underlying cause. It has four elements, which have appeared in past papers:
| Element | Meaning | Classic example |
|---|---|---|
| Asl | The original case in the text | Wine (khamr) |
| Far' | The new case | Another intoxicant, such as nabidh or drugs |
| 'Illah | The effective cause common to both | Intoxication |
| Hukm | The rule of the original case | Prohibition |
Because the new intoxicant shares the 'illah of intoxication, the rule of prohibition is extended to it. The Zahiri and Ja'fari schools rejected qiyas.
Secondary methods
When the four sources do not give a clear answer, jurists use further methods, each linked to a particular school:
| Method | Meaning | Mainly associated with |
|---|---|---|
| Istihsan | Juristic preference: departing from strict analogy for a stronger reason | Hanafi |
| Maslaha mursala (istislah) | Considering unregulated public interest | Maliki |
| Istishab | Presuming that a previous state of affairs continues until changed | Shafi'i |
| 'Urf | Custom, where it does not conflict with the texts | Hanafi and Maliki |
| Sadd al-dhara'i | Blocking the means to harm | Maliki |
| Qawl al-sahabi | Opinion of a Companion | Hanafi |
HEC tests these by asking which term matches a definition. For example, "presumption of continuity of an earlier rule" is istishab. "Juristic preference" is istihsan. "Public interest method" is maslaha mursala.
Comparing with Salmond's sources
LAW-GAT also tests Salmond's sources of law. 'Urf corresponds to custom, the Qur'an and Sunnah have the authority Salmond attributes to legislation, and ijma works somewhat like a settled body of authority. Do not push the comparison too far in the exam. It is only a memory aid. Read sources of law according to Salmond to compare.
Pakistan's constitutional link
Article 227 of the Constitution of Pakistan requires all existing laws to be brought into conformity with the Injunctions of Islam as laid down in the Holy Qur'an and Sunnah. The Federal Shariat Court tests laws against that standard under Article 203D. This is why the Qur'an and Sunnah appear by name in constitutional MCQs, for example Art. 31 in our list of important articles of the Constitution.
Practise and revise
Learn the table of secondary methods and the four elements of qiyas, then drill the Islamic jurisprudence MCQs. Use Practice mode to learn the answers, and Revision mode (45 seconds per question) to get fast. For the basic vocabulary, read usul al-fiqh basics from Nyazee, and for the five categories of rules, see hukm shar'i categories explained.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the four primary sources of Islamic law in order?
The Qur'an, the Sunnah, Ijma (consensus) and Qiyas (analogy), in that order. This order is commonly traced to the hadith of Mu'adh bin Jabal.
What are the elements of qiyas?
Qiyas has four elements: asl (the original case), far' (the new case), 'illah (the effective cause shared by both) and hukm (the rule of the original case that is extended to the new one).
Which schools rejected qiyas?
The Zahiri school and the Ja'fari (Shia) school did not accept qiyas as a source of law.
What is istishab?
Istishab is the presumption that a state of affairs known to have existed continues until there is evidence that it has changed. For example, a person known to be alive is presumed alive until his death is proved. It is mainly associated with the Shafi'i school.
Practise this topic
Test what you just read with real HEC past-paper questions.