Appeal, Revision and Review in CPC: Key Differences for LAW-GAT

· 6 min read

In this guide
  1. The one-line distinction
  2. Appeal under the CPC
  3. Revision under section 115 CPC
  4. Review under section 114 and Order XLVII
  5. Side-by-side comparison
  6. Related powers to remember
  7. Practise the pattern
  8. Frequently Asked Questions

"What is the difference between appeal, revision and review?" is a classic LLB exam question, and LAW-GAT tests the same ground through short MCQs on sections 96, 100, 104, 114 and 115 of the CPC. All three are ways of challenging a court's decision, but they differ in who hears them, what grounds are allowed and how wide the scrutiny is. This guide sets out the difference in a way you can recall in the 45 seconds you have per question.

The one-line distinction

  • Appeal: a higher court re-examines the decision on facts and law. It is a statutory right.
  • Revision: the High Court (and, in some matters, the District Court) checks whether a subordinate court acted within its jurisdiction and without material irregularity. It is a discretionary, supervisory power.
  • Review: the same court re-looks at its own decision on narrow grounds such as an error apparent on the face of the record.

Appeal under the CPC

First appeal (section 96)

Section 96(1) says an appeal lies from every decree passed by a court exercising original jurisdiction, to the court authorised to hear appeals from that court. Points HEC tests:

  • Section 96(2): an appeal lies from an original decree passed ex parte.
  • Section 96(3): no appeal lies from a decree passed by the court with the consent of parties.
  • A first appeal is a rehearing on both facts and law.

Second appeal (section 100)

A second appeal lies to the High Court from a decree passed in appeal by a subordinate court, but only on limited grounds, chiefly that the decision is contrary to law, has failed to decide a material issue of law, or suffers from a substantial error or defect in procedure. A second appeal is not a fresh look at facts.

Appeals from orders (section 104 and Order XLIII)

Not every order is appealable. Section 104 and Order XLIII Rule 1 list the appealable orders, for example an order returning a plaint under Order VII Rule 10, or orders on temporary injunctions under Order XXXIX. Section 104(2) adds that no appeal lies from an order passed in appeal under that section.

The procedure for appeals is in Order XLI, covered in our guide to most tested CPC Orders and Rules.

Revision under section 115 CPC

The High Court may call for the record of any case decided by a court subordinate to it in which no appeal lies, and interfere if that court appears:

  1. to have exercised a jurisdiction not vested in it by law;
  2. to have failed to exercise a jurisdiction so vested; or
  3. to have acted in the exercise of its jurisdiction illegally or with material irregularity.

These three grounds are the heart of every revision question. A favourite LAW-GAT trap offers "failing to exercise a jurisdiction not vested" as an option; that is not a ground.

Other Pakistan-specific points from section 115:

  • An application for revision is to be made within ninety days of the decision, as provided in the proviso to section 115(1).
  • Section 115(2) gives the District Court revisional powers in certain cases.
  • Under section 115(4), no revision lies to the High Court against an order of the District Court made under section 115(2).

Revision is discretionary: even where a ground exists, the court may decline to interfere if no injustice has been caused.

Review under section 114 and Order XLVII

Section 114 gives the right to apply for review to any person aggrieved by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed but has not been preferred, from which no appeal is allowed, or by a decision on a reference from a Court of Small Causes. Order XLVII Rule 1 sets the grounds:

  1. discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence, was not within his knowledge or could not be produced when the decree was passed;
  2. some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record; or
  3. any other sufficient reason.

Review is heard by the same court that passed the decision. It is not a disguised appeal; re-arguing the merits is not allowed.

Side-by-side comparison

PointAppealRevisionReview
ProvisionSs. 96, 100, 104; O. XLI, XLIIIS. 115S. 114; O. XLVII
Heard byHigher (appellate) courtHigh Court, or District Court in some casesSame court
NatureStatutory rightDiscretionary supervisory powerLimited power to correct own errors
ScopeFacts and law (first appeal)Jurisdictional errors and material irregularityNew evidence, error apparent on the record, sufficient reason
Available whenAppeal provided by lawNo appeal liesAppeal not filed or not available
  • Section 151: inherent powers to make orders necessary for the ends of justice or to prevent abuse of process. Courts use it only where no specific provision applies.
  • Section 152: correction of clerical or arithmetical mistakes in judgments, decrees or orders at any time. This is not a review.
  • Section 12(2): challenge to a decree obtained by fraud, misrepresentation or want of jurisdiction, by application to the court that passed it.

For the full list of sections to revise, see CPC 1908 important sections for LAW-GAT.

Practise the pattern

Sample questions from past papers:

  1. Section 96(1): appeal lies from every decree of a court of original jurisdiction.
  2. Section 115: limitation for revision is 90 days.
  3. Section 104 deals with orders from which appeal lies.
  4. Section 151 saves the court's inherent power.

Attempt the full set in the Civil Procedure Code MCQs, first in Practice mode and then Test mode. When CPC feels solid, move on to the criminal side of the syllabus, where appeals and revision work differently.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a person file revision if an appeal is available?

Ordinarily no. Section 115 applies to a case in which no appeal lies. Where an appeal is available, the aggrieved party should file the appeal.

Who hears a review petition?

The same court that passed the decree or order. That is the key difference between review and both appeal and revision.

Is an appeal a right and revision a discretion?

Yes. An appeal is a creature of statute and, where provided, is a right. Revision is a discretionary supervisory jurisdiction, and the court may refuse to interfere even if an error exists.

What is the limitation for revision under section 115 CPC?

The proviso to section 115(1) requires a revision application to be made within ninety days of the decision of the subordinate court.

Keep reading