Supreme Court and High Court Jurisdiction in Pakistan

· 6 min read

In this guide
  1. Supreme Court jurisdiction in Pakistan
  2. High Court jurisdiction: Article 199
  3. Federal Shariat Court
  4. Contempt and judicial accountability
  5. How to remember all this
  6. Frequently Asked Questions

Questions on the judicature are among the most predictable in LAW-GAT. If you know which article gives which jurisdiction, and the small details around it, you can get several Constitution MCQs right. This guide explains Supreme Court and High Court jurisdiction in Pakistan as the 1973 Constitution sets it out.

Supreme Court jurisdiction in Pakistan

The Supreme Court is established under Article 175, and its permanent seat is Islamabad (Art. 183). Its main jurisdictions are listed below.

ArticleJurisdictionIn one line
184(1)OriginalDisputes between governments (Federal and Provincial)
184(3)OriginalQuestions of public importance involving fundamental rights
185AppellateAppeals from High Courts
186AdvisoryPresident refers a question of law
186ATransferTransfer of cases between High Courts
187Complete justiceIssue directions, orders or decrees
188ReviewReview of its own judgments

Original jurisdiction: Article 184

Under Article 184(1), the Supreme Court has exclusive original jurisdiction in disputes between any two or more governments. The Court can only give a declaratory judgment in such a dispute (Art. 184(2)).

Article 184(3) is the famous one. If the Court considers that a question of public importance about the enforcement of a fundamental right is involved, it can make orders of the kind a High Court makes under Article 199. Most of the big constitutional cases were filed under it, including Nusrat Bhutto, Zafar Ali Shah and Khan Asfandyar Wali. See our landmark constitutional cases post.

Appellate jurisdiction: Article 185

Some appeals lie as of right under Article 185(2). Examples are where a High Court has reversed an acquittal and sentenced the accused to death or to imprisonment for life, has imposed a death sentence, or has punished a person for contempt of the High Court. HEC has asked about the contempt example. Every other appeal needs leave to appeal under Article 185(3), which the Court grants at its discretion.

Advisory jurisdiction: Article 186

The President may refer any question of law of public importance to the Supreme Court for its opinion. The Court considers it and reports its opinion to the President. Past papers have offered "question of fact" as a wrong option, so do not pick it.

Review and binding effect: Articles 188 to 190

  • Art. 188: the Supreme Court may review any judgment or order it has made.
  • Art. 189: a Supreme Court decision that decides a question of law or is based on or enunciates a principle of law binds all other courts in Pakistan.
  • Art. 190: all executive and judicial authorities throughout Pakistan shall act in aid of the Supreme Court.

Recent restructuring

The 26th Amendment (2024) introduced constitutional benches of the Supreme Court and High Courts to hear constitutional matters, including Article 184(3) and Article 199 cases. Later amendments reorganised constitutional jurisdiction further. LAW-GAT past papers have been based on the long-standing text, but read the current bare act and check the latest syllabus notice on hec.gov.pk before your exam.

High Court jurisdiction: Article 199

Every province has a High Court, and there is also the Islamabad High Court. A High Court's most important constitutional power is the writ jurisdiction under Article 199. It applies only if no other adequate remedy is provided by law.

ClauseWritWhat it doesWho can apply
199(1)(a)(i)Prohibition / MandamusStops an authority acting unlawfully, or orders it to do its legal dutyAggrieved party
199(1)(a)(ii)CertiorariDeclares an act or order made without lawful authority voidAggrieved party
199(1)(b)(i)Habeas corpusProduce a person held in custody so the court can confirm the detention is lawfulAny person
199(1)(b)(ii)Quo warrantoAsks a person by what authority they hold public officeAny person
199(1)(c)Enforcement of fundamental rightsDirections to enforce Chapter 1 rightsAggrieved person

Remember this distinction. Habeas corpus and quo warranto can be sought by any person, but the other writs need an aggrieved party. In the Tamizuddin case, the writs sought were mandamus and quo warranto, which HEC has asked about.

Article 199(3) bars writs at the instance of members of the Armed Forces in matters relating to their terms of service.

Other High Court articles

  • Art. 193: qualifications. A person must have been an advocate of a High Court, or held judicial office, for ten years.
  • Art. 194: the Chief Justice of a High Court takes oath before the Governor.
  • Art. 195: a High Court judge retires at 62.
  • Art. 198: seats and benches. Benches are fixed by the Governor on the advice of the Cabinet and in consultation with the Chief Justice.
  • Art. 201: a High Court decision on a question of law binds the courts subordinate to it.
  • Art. 203: every High Court supervises and controls all courts subordinate to it.

Federal Shariat Court

Under Article 203C, the Federal Shariat Court consists of eight Muslim judges, including the Chief Justice. Under Article 203D, it can examine whether any law is repugnant to the Injunctions of Islam. Appeals go to the Shariat Appellate Bench of the Supreme Court.

Contempt and judicial accountability

  • Art. 204: the Supreme Court and High Courts can punish for contempt. "Court" here means the Supreme Court or a High Court.
  • Art. 209: the Supreme Judicial Council inquires into the capacity or conduct of superior court judges.
  • Art. 211: SJC proceedings cannot be called into question in any court.

How to remember all this

Make a two-column sheet with SC articles on one side and HC articles on the other, and test yourself by covering one side. Then do the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 MCQs in Revision mode, where you get 45 seconds per question and the answer is shown after you choose. Also read our list of important articles of the Constitution. For civil appeals and revisions under ordinary law, compare with appeal, revision and review under CPC.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Article 184(3) and Article 199?

Article 184(3) gives the Supreme Court original jurisdiction where a question of public importance involves the enforcement of fundamental rights. Article 199 gives High Courts writ jurisdiction, which an aggrieved party can generally invoke where there is no other adequate remedy. Public importance is not required under Article 199.

Which writs can be filed by any person?

Habeas corpus (Art. 199(1)(b)(i)) and quo warranto (Art. 199(1)(b)(ii)) can be sought on the application of any person. Mandamus, prohibition and certiorari need an aggrieved party.

What is the retirement age of Supreme Court and High Court judges?

A Supreme Court judge retires at 65 (Art. 179) and a High Court judge at 62 (Art. 195).

Is the Supreme Court bound by its own decisions?

No. Article 189 binds all other courts, and the Supreme Court can review its own judgments under Article 188 and depart from earlier rulings in later cases.

Keep reading